Cleansing Balms for Makeup Removal: What to Know About 8 Editor-Tested Picks

Cleansing balms can help remove makeup, sunscreen and excess oil without the tight, dry feeling some people get from traditional cleansers. Editors who tried the products below favored them for different reasons, from easy-to-use packaging to a soft finish. Their experiences are useful for comparing formulas, though they don’t establish that one balm will suit every skin type.

Dermatologist Marisa Garshick, MD, FAAD, says balms work by dissolving makeup, sunscreen, oil and impurities. Many turn milky when mixed with water, which helps them rinse away while leaving skin feeling soft. She says they may be especially appealing for mature, dry or sensitive skin, which can be more prone to dryness and irritation from repeated rubbing.

How to fit a balm into a cleansing routine

A balm is often used as the oil-based first step in double cleansing, followed by a water-based cleanser. That second step is a personal choice rather than a requirement. Garshick says it may help people who wear heavy makeup or water-resistant sunscreen, or who prefer a deeper-feeling cleanse. People with dry or sensitive skin should be mindful that washing too much can add to irritation and dryness.

Product formulas also differ. Some focus on oils and a moisturizing feel; others include exfoliating ingredients or fragrance that may not suit everyone. An editor’s report that a product felt gentle or didn’t cause breakouts describes that person’s experience, not a guarantee for other users.

Editor-tested balm options

Colleen Rothschild Radiant Cleansing Balm: Moringa oil helps dissolve makeup and impurities, while loofah seed extract is described as refining and flaxseed oil as softening. The editor who tested it said it removed a full face of foundation and left skin feeling hydrated and glowing. She had finished two jars and returned to the product when she wanted a thorough cleanse.

Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm: This formula changes from balm to oil and then to a milk when rinsed with water. Its essential-oil blend includes lavender, chamomile and eucalyptus; other versions include Black Cherry, Green Fig, Rose and an unscented option. Starflower oil and padina pavonica, a type of macroalgae, are included for skin-barrier support and dry-skin comfort. Those sensitive to fragrance may prefer to pay attention to the unscented version.

Banila Clean It Zero Original: The writer’s first balm, this pick is presented as an approachable option for someone trying the format. The source says it removes makeup and impurities and contains acerola berry and vitamin C, ingredients associated with antioxidant support and radiance.

The Inkey List Oat Cleansing Balm: The updated formula contains 5% oat kernel oil, increased from 3%, and is described as supporting hydration and the skin barrier. It has a thick, buttery texture that melts into an oil. Associate Reviews Editor Hannah Jeon said that after about two months of use it removed makeup, sunscreen and waterproof mascara without leaving her skin dry. She also liked the soothing feel and squeeze-tube packaging. The source identifies it as an option for sensitive, eczema-prone skin, but individual tolerance can vary.

Eve Lom Cleansing Balm: Deputy editor Eunice Lucero-Lee described using it as a home-spa experience. Its botanical oil blend is said to melt away makeup and grime while leaving skin smooth and moisturized. The product is more expensive than many cleansers, and a muslin cloth is included for added exfoliation. Anyone whose skin is easily irritated may want to consider how a cloth and extra exfoliation fit into their routine.

Then I Met You Living Cleansing Balm: This K-beauty balm has a soft, sorbet-like texture that emulsifies with water. Its vitamin E and persimmon are described as antioxidant-rich ingredients, and the formula is positioned for combination-to-oily skin. The brand suggests following it with a water-based gel cleanser. That pairing may appeal to people who prefer two steps, though it’s not necessary for everyone.

True Botanicals cleansing balm: Turmeric and ginger root are included for their calming and brightening properties. The formula also contains lactic and azelaic acids, which can exfoliate and smooth skin texture. Because those ingredients may be too harsh for sensitive skin, this option calls for extra attention to how the formula feels on an individual’s skin. Reviewers cited in the source liked its luxurious texture, makeup removal and soft finish.

A fragrance-free balm with twist-top packaging: The writer tried this product in Korea and praised its dispenser, which releases balm without requiring fingers to reach into a jar. The fragrance-free formula was described as gentle, and some reviewers said it didn’t cause breakouts. One drawback reported by the writer: using enough to remove makeup meant going through the jar quickly. The source doesn’t provide the product name, so it can’t be identified confidently here.

A cleansing oil as another option

Burt’s Bees cleansing oil is included as an alternative for people who find balms too aggressive. Garshick says a non-comedogenic oil may help dissolve sebum, sunscreen and makeup without clogging pores or leaving a heavy residue. Senior Commerce Editor Charlotte Finigan said this oil removed mineral sunscreen without causing breakouts for her. The formula is described as containing natural seed oils, coconut oil and argan oil.

The practical choice depends on what you need to remove and how your skin responds. If cleansing leaves skin persistently dry or irritated, or you’re unsure whether a product suits a skin condition, a doctor or pharmacist can help you weigh the ingredients and routine.